It almost seemed like a mistake when the Giants’ lineup card was posted.
Steven Duggar, the best defensive outfielder on the roster, was listed in left field. Alex Dickerson was the right fielder for just the second time in his big league career.
It seemed like a mixup, but Gabe Kapler explained before Monday’s game why it made sense. Left field at Coors Field has significantly more real estate than right, and the gap is much harder to play on that side of the field. Kapler said the staff had gone over the spray charts for Rockies hitters and decided it made more sense to put Duggar, who had two previous professional innings in left, there Monday.
“It’s a little bit unpredictable,” Kapler said in the afternoon. “Sometimes you get that right and sometimes you don’t.”
A few hours later, it felt like the decision ended up being costly. Dickerson, who previously had only played right when Brandon Belt was the left fielder, had two misplays in the five-run sixth inning of a 7-6 loss to the Rockies.
[BALK TALK: Listen to the latest episode]
With the Giants up by a run, Ryan McMahon hit a one-out shot to right that Dickerson got a glove on as his feet hit the warning track. But he bobbled the ball and dropped it as McMahon raced into third. The Rockies took the lead later in the inning on a single to right that turned into a two-run play when Dickerson’s throw back to the infield overshot the cutoff man. Pitcher Wandy Peralta and catcher Chadwick Tromp ended up converging on the ball near the dugout as the trail runner easily took a vacated plate.
Kapler said a night like that does lead to second-guessing, but he added that “sometimes you set them up and you set them up the right way and it doesn’t work out.”
“In hindsight, you question was that the right call. Honestly I bet Dick makes that (catch) 19 out of 20 times,” Kapler said. “The throw, I bet he makes almost every time. There’s no question.”
The Giants were confident in their process, but at this point it might be hard to be too confident in how those decisions will play out on the field. The defense has been a mess through 11 games, a bit of a surprise given the intensity of both camps. They lead the NL with 13 errors. Evan Longoria booted a grounder in the first inning that led to the first run off Johnny Cueto, who was later charged with two more on a Nolan Arenado homer.
That blast, Arenado’s first of the year, started the five-run outburst. The Rockies kept tacking on thanks to the defensive mistakes, and perhaps the pre-game decision.
[RELATED:How Giants are developing players at alternate site]
Dickerson said the switch might have factored in “a little bit” on the angles he took and said something caught his eye on the throw, perhaps because he was in an unfamiliar spot. But Dickerson said there were no excuses, and those were plays that should have been made regardless of his lack of experience in right.
“At the end of the day you’re still an athlete,” he said. “You’ve got to be able to go catch a ball like that. I just kind of had one of those innings where there were two big flukes that really cost us.”